Well if theres one thing i think every artist agrees on it's that an honest opinion is better than one that sounds good. if you're lucky, the honest opinion DOES sound good, but you can't expect that all the time.
we've discussed the drag-queen-iness of the sketch, though i don't nessecarily agree. the v-neck appearance is admittedly not quite as it should've been. i've been thinking of an alternative, which resembles the old 16th century half cloaks that would go around the shoulders. it'd, for lack of a better description, look like a very narrow upside down v. tied at the top and opening slightly below. a cloak over the robe itself, acting as a kind of rain-guard for the shoulders. i can picture it's application in the pic very well.
as for your comments on WIPs, i think most people will agree that most if not ALL the pics i've put up here are chronically WIPs. the semi-complete ones are ones with finalised line-art, and those tend to be posted twice or three times, with the last being the so called semi-complete ones. until colours start hitting my pics, they will never be anything more than heavily worked on WIPs, even in the best of cases. also remember these are sketches. i'm not sure about how people percieve sketches in general, but where mine are conscerned, they're almost always WIPs by nature.
and again, harsh delivery aside, i like honest opinions. I value constructive criticism. but as a side note, i'd appreciate some constructive suggestions as to how this can be improved. i will say what i can currently see wrong in the pic. feel free to add to it: arms need correcting. hood needs some adjustment, the squiggles under the hood need to be removed and replaced. more detail on the robe itself. possibly shrink the Executioner's form in comparison to the pic to fit everything in [i am admittedly VERY bad at that >_<]
this is, as i said before, a neutral appearance of the Executioner. this is NOT the thing in the RPGs. not appearance-wise. the personality in RPGTEW is just that: a personality. the mindset of the Executioner towards his role. absolute. unwavering. not to be depended on as a standard on which to base 'on duty' behaviour. i think many have already noticed the ISS Executioner is some enormous black, completely insane beast that comes up suddenly, destroys whatever it is that needs to be destroyed, and just as suddenly disappears again. the only thing shared between the Executioner there and the entity in the pic is that both are pitch black to the point it's almost unnatural [in the entity's case, definately unnatural]...
so, now i've responded to your comment in every way i can see (

)...any suggestions?